Keeping in line with its recent tradition of waffling on the issue of team selection for test matches, Pakistan Cricket Board, again released two players and added four others for the first test match against Sri Lanka starting in Rawalpindi tomorrow. While addition of Aamer Jamal, could be a welcome step, but dropping opener
Abdullah Fazal, who recently scored a triple century in the President Trophy and left arm spinner Ali Usman was quite strange and inexplicable.
Ali Usman was also among the seven players sent home during Test series against England a few months ago. This decision was highly criticised by the experts and former players as in about 150 years of history of the Test cricket, such a large number of a team members were never replaced by a new group of players.
Inconsistency in selection of the team selection has become a trademark of the present selection committee of the PCB led by Aqib Javed.
Such U-turns not only affect the morale of the players dumped unceremoniously but also creates doubts in the minds of entire squad. Players get confused by sudden replacement of team colleagues having good recent performance. The question arises why Abdullah Fazal and Ali Usman were selected in the first place if the board was not satisfied with their performance. If a triple century is not enough for selection for the PCB selection panel, what will the the criteria for a batter selection. Similarly Ali Usman also has performed well in both Test matches and the first class cricket. One justification being given for dropping Usman is that the team did not need services of two left arm leg spinners – the other being Arafat Minhas. But the panel should have considered this fact before selection of both of them. Then there should have been given a solid reason for replacing Abdullah Fazal, if it was necessary.
Cricket teams selection needs consistently and showing faith in the selected players. Too much tickering in the squad badly affects the team morale and outcome of the matches. Salman Ali Agha, also a victim of this ficklemindedness during England series has stated that such decisions were not good for the interest of the game. On return he scored a triple century and got selected for the Test squad, but other triple century maker, who was among seven replacements during England tour, was first named in Rawalpindi Test squad,but suddenly dumped two days before the start of the match. Interestingly, he was not selected for third and last Test in England despite scoring two half-centuries in his two tests against Bangladesh.
Overall he has scored 141 runs with the average of 35.2 which is not bad for a newcomer. In recently played President Trophy, he scored 437 runs at an average of 38.55. His replacement, Tayyab Arif has played only seven first class matches and scored 727 runs with average of 66.09 runs per innings. He is very young and inexperienced.
Ali Usman has taken 12 wickets in four test matches at the average of 25.41 per wicket.
The PCB selection criteria is a quandary for cricket experts and former players. For example, left hand opener Saim Ayub was named among 7 replacements during England tour on the basis of century in a T20 match during Caribbean Premier League. The boy could not score a single run in Edgbaston Test and suffer the ignominy of a pair. All cricket pundits know that playing in English conditions needs practice and exposure to those conditions but throwing a person direct from West Indies, to English fast bowlers in extremely difficult and different conditions was highly mind-blowing.
One more point worth a mention is inclusion of many all rounders in the squad named for Rawalpindi test match. All rounders, some times can be helpful in white ball cricket but in Test matches, specialists are always preferred. For test matches, all rounders like Imran Khan, Jacques Kallis, Kapil Dev make real difference. White ball all rounders often fail to make much difference in Test matches. Indian all-rounder Hardik Pandya has spectacular record in both One Day International matches and T20is, but he has only played 11 test matches. The Indian selection panel know that Test cricket is a different ball game and needs specialist players.
With Pakistan placed at the bottom of World Test Championship, the team selectors needed to select experienced players but they have opted for very young and inexperienced top three batters. Similarly in the bowling department,they had already dropped Sajid Khan and Nauman Ali and now they have shown the door to Ali Usman as well. It means that except for Muhammad Abbas and Aamer Jamal, the Pakistan team will have to rely on inexperienced, rather raw bowling attack.




